Producing high-quality, in-depth news takes significant resources. At Lake Lure News / Cops & Congress, facts come first, followed by in-depth commentary and analysis. Your subscription helps support independent journalism that brings you closer to the decisions shaping the community and ensures I can continue delivering the stories that matter most.
Situational awareness: An exclusive, or scoop is an important news story that is first reported by a journalist. This goes beyond breaking news when no other journalists are known to be reporting on an important issue.
Public Voices Concerns Over Chimney Rock Access at NCDOT Meeting
Proposed temporary bridge sparks debate over environmental and historic impacts
LAKE LURE, N.C. — A highly anticipated public input meeting hosted by the North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) on Wednesday evening brought together local and state officials and concerned residents to discuss potential road access solutions for Chimney Rock State Park. The meeting at Lake Lure Classical Academy became a platform for passionate discussions about the future of transportation infrastructure in the area, particularly regarding the construction of a temporary bridge on Southside Drive.
Setting the Stage
The meeting, which took place from 5-7 p.m., saw a steady stream of attendees walking through the gymnasium space, reviewing maps, and engaging in discussions with officials. Large maps displayed on easels provided a visual representation of the proposed routes, while officials stood ready to answer questions and record public comments.
Upon arriving at the meeting, I observed several key figures in attendance, including the mayor of Chimney Rock, residents, and various stakeholders. Some had already reviewed the materials and were leaving as I arrived, but many remained inside, eager to voice their opinions.
The Temporary Bridge Proposal
One of the most discussed topics of the evening was the proposed temporary bridge on Southside Drive, intended to provide access to Chimney Rock State Park while permanent solutions are evaluated and constructed. However, concerns about the plan quickly surfaced. Many residents expressed skepticism over whether this option was the best long-term solution, raising questions about its environmental impact, historic preservation considerations, and feasibility.
Brian Burch, the contracted NCDOT project manager, acknowledged these concerns exclusively to me but said that all options were still being considered. “No final decisions have been made,” Burch said.
The temporary bridge, which has been the only publicly released map for temporary access, has sparked debate over whether its construction would require significant alterations to the surrounding area. “If we impact any of the historic aspects of Chimney Rock Park, it’s got to go through the State Historic Preservation Office and the National Park Service,” Burch explained, emphasizing that the approval process could take up to a year or more.
Public Sentiment and Environmental Concerns
Residents and local officials alike voiced concerns about the environmental and historic implications of the temporary bridge project. Several attendees pointed out that Southside Drive is currently a single-lane road, meaning it would need to be widened to accommodate increased traffic. “Right now, what we have seen on our research is that there’s a 30-foot right of way or easement through there, which would probably allow us to widen the road,” Burch said. However, he admitted that additional easements might be required, which would add complexity and time to the project.
Another key issue raised was the impact on local wildlife and vegetation. The proposed widening of Southside Drive would require the removal of trees and could potentially disrupt existing ecosystems. Burch noted that any environmental impacts would be thoroughly reviewed but acknowledged that changes to the landscape were inevitable.
Alternative Routes and the Lago Vista Drive Proposal
As discussions continued, some residents asked whether Lago Vista Drive could serve as an alternative temporary access route. This suggestion, however, was quickly dismissed by state officials. Brian Strong, Director of North Carolina State Parks, stated that the road would require significant upgrades to meet state standards. “It would need about $3.5 million worth of work,” Strong explained. “It couldn’t be gravel. Gravel wouldn’t be acceptable.”
The cost and engineering challenges associated with upgrading Lago Vista Drive made it an unlikely candidate for temporary access. Strong elaborated that the project would require extensive retaining walls, environmental considerations, and additional infrastructure, making it impractical given the urgency of the access issue. “By the time you put the retaining walls in, you get all of that work done, and all the environmental work is complete, it might as well be a permanent road,” he added.
What Happens Next?
With the March 12 public comment deadline fast approaching, NCDOT officials emphasized that they are still gathering input from residents and stakeholders. According to Burch, once all comments are compiled, the project team will analyze the feedback and discuss potential revisions. A follow-up meeting has already been scheduled for March 19, during which the team will review public concerns and decide on the next steps.
“We will go through and see what the most common concerns are and lump those together,” Burch said. “From there, we’ll meet with stakeholders—including Chimney Rock Village, the State Park, and Lake Lure—to determine the best path forward.”
The NCDOT aims to finalize its decision-making process by the end of March. Officials hope to communicate the final access plan to the public shortly thereafter, with an anticipated construction start date in April 2025.
Community Reactions
While the NCDOT has reiterated its commitment to considering public input, some residents remain skeptical about whether alternative options are truly on the table. One attendee, who only identified himself as Greg, told me, “It seems almost like a foregone conclusion that they’re going with Southside Drive, despite saying they’re considering all options.”
Officials maintained that community feedback remains a critical component of the decision-making process. “We appreciate everybody coming out and providing input,” Burch said. “It’s important for us to understand what the public wants so that we can make the best decision moving forward.”
What’s Next?
As the debate over Chimney Rock access continues, residents and stakeholders are encouraged to submit their comments before the deadline. The coming weeks will be crucial in determining how the NCDOT proceeds with its plans and whether public feedback will lead to project scope adjustments.
Opinion & Analysis: Cops & Congress Commentary
Cops & Congress Commentary: 5 Things I’m Watching in the Chimney Rock Access Debate
As discussions continue over how to improve access to Chimney Rock State Park, several key factors will ultimately shape the direction of this project. Here are five things I’m closely watching as this process unfolds:
Environmental Impact and Historic Preservation
The proposed temporary bridge on Southside Drive has raised concerns about the environmental consequences, such as tree removal and disruptions to local wildlife habitats. Additionally, there are questions about how the construction might affect the park’s historic integrity. Will these concerns be addressed adequately, or will they be overlooked for the sake of expediency? This is a critical issue that could shape how future projects are handled in this area.Public Input – Will it Matter?
Residents have voiced their concerns about whether the state is truly considering all options, especially in light of past experiences where public input didn’t always lead to significant changes. With the comment deadline looming, I’m watching closely to see if the NCDOT genuinely incorporates the feedback it receives. If residents’ concerns are dismissed in favor of moving forward quickly, it could damage the public’s trust in future infrastructure projects.Alternatives to Southside Drive
The Lago Vista Drive proposal was quickly dismissed due to its high cost and engineering challenges, but I’m still watching to see if any other alternatives emerge. While Lago Vista may not be feasible, are there other options that could balance both the urgency of the project and the need for environmental and historic preservation? It's worth exploring other routes before settling on the temporary bridge.Financial Considerations
This project will come with a hefty price tag. Between the temporary bridge, road widening, and potential environmental mitigation efforts, the costs could skyrocket. How will the state balance the need for immediate access with the financial constraints of the project? I’m particularly interested in how the budget plays out, especially given the long-term impact on taxpayers.Timeline and Construction Start
With construction slated to begin in April 2025, I’m watching to see if the timeline holds. Will the NCDOT stick to its proposed schedule, or will delays push the project further into the future? Additionally, how quickly will the community see the benefits of improved access? I’ll be paying attention to the timeline and whether the state can deliver on its promises.
The next few weeks will be crucial in determining how this project moves forward. As the public input comment deadline approaches, I’ll be watching these five factors closely to see if the NCDOT can strike a balance between providing better access to Chimney Rock State Park and protecting what makes it so unique.
Thank you for reading and watching. Learn more about this newsletter and my background. I am guided by the Society for Professional Journalists Code of Ethics. Follow me on X (Twitter), Facebook, Linkedin, Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube. Send constructive criticism, fan mail and tips with public documents for future stories: CopsandCongress@gmail.com.
Share this post